Notes from underground

يارب يسوع المسيح ابن اللّه الحيّ إرحمني أنا الخاطئ

Taking your political temperature

About 18 months ago I looked at the test on the Political Compass to see where the US presidential hopefuls stood. All of them, with the exception of Dennis Kucinich and Mike Gravel, were on the authoritarian right. I found I was on the libertarian left, in about much the same place as Nelson Mandela, which is no doubt why I voted for him.

Now Jams O’Donnell at The Poor Mouth: Political Spectrum has found another site, The Political Spectrum, which does much the same thing, but from an American viewpoint.

Here is my result:

My Political Views
I am a left social moderate
Left: 3.86, Libertarian: 0.9

Political Spectrum Quiz

The result was not very much different from Political Compass, but a little less libertarian so not much surprise there.

My Political Compass results were:

Economic Left/Right: -6.50
Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -4.00

Nor is there much surprise in these results on Political Spectrum:

My Foreign Policy Views
Score: -5.73

Political Spectrum Quiz

My Culture War Stance
Score: -2.57

Political Spectrum Quiz

But the tests are like chalk and cheese.

The Political Compass has carefully-worded questions, designed to be clear and unambiguous, and where the answers will actually measure something.

In the Political Spectrum test the questions are biased, tendentious, and very often beg the question, and it is difficult to see what they are trying to measure.

The Political Compass did not give the opportunity for a neutral answer, but it wasn’t needed, because the questions were clear and unambiguous.

The Political Spectrum gave the opportunity for neutral answers, and also gave the opportunity of indicating the importance of the issue. In theory this should make the test more accurate, but in fact I answered most questions as neutral, and of neutral or little importance, because of the bad wording.

I can’t remember the exact wording now, without going back and doing the tests again, but one example that struck me was that the Political Compass test asked something like:

Do you think that abortion should be legal for a woman when there is no danger to her life?

whereas the Political Spectrum equivalent version was something like:

Do you think that the state should deny a woman her right to an abortion?

which begs more than one question.

The difference may be because Political Compass is a serious exercise and appears to have drawn on professional expertise in designing the questionnaire and formulating the questions. The Political Spectrum one is on a public quiz site, where anyone can post a questionnaire, and there is nothing to prevent the wording of the questions reflecting the biases of the compiler.

But I can’t help wondering whether it is also perhaps a reflection of the differences between British and American culture.

And now, with a general election looming, I wonder where our own political leaders stand.

I imagine Jacob Zuma would be a circle in all four quadrants, getting a different result depending on the last person he spoke to.

I also suspect that Patricia de Lille is still closest to my position (and that of Nelson Mandela).

Advertisements

Single Post Navigation

6 thoughts on “Taking your political temperature

  1. Harry Haddock on said:

    All of them, with the exception of Dennis Kucinich and Mike Gravel, were on the authoritarian right.

    Oh come on.. Ron Paul? Authoritarian right?

  2. Steve Hayes on said:

    Henry,

    I forgot to mention Ralph Nader, who also appears on the libertarian left. Mike Gravel is on the libertarian right, while Ron Paul is close to the borderline.

  3. Harry Haddock on said:

    Well, I took the test and it put me in the extreme libertarian right. Therein is the problem with such tests. It got the ‘social’ and ‘anti war’ bits right ~ in that I am a complete social libertarian, and completely anti war, but I would argue that there is no such thing as a ‘right’ or ‘left’ libertarian.

    If you start from the standpoint that libertarian’s believe that individuals know best what works for themselves, or if not, that nobody has a God given right to tell them what to do, or what is ‘better’ for them, then I believe it is only consistent to apply this to all areas of life (personal, economics, etc etc), with the state just there to run the rule of law, i.e. to settle disputes and protect against coercion.

    Thus I often thing ‘right’ libertarians are those who think everyone should be free in one area of their lives (economics) but can’t be trusted with their own personal liberty, whereas left libertarians tend to think that people have an absolute right to personal liberty, but appear to think that this shouldn’t apply to economics, which is after all just another human interaction.

  4. Pingback: Taking your political temperature redux | Notes from underground

  5. The tests are fun – but they all seem constructed with the assumption most people taking them will be on the far authoritarian right.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: